Thursday 1 December 2016

Seeking Signal in the Noise

Climate Change, Ranga Myneni, Foetus, Colonialism, “Fees Must Fall”, Gramsci, Fanon – what is the link between  these issues and names?  I admit - I have an agenda.  Throwing these “randoms” at you is an attempt to buy your engagement. I am trying to engage you in a “meaning-making” exercise as an exercise in agency and  citizenship of this fantastic country.

The common link is an intended emotional  fruit that is, in my opinon, diabolical. This is a strong word but I am happy to use it. For, if you stay with the programme over this series, you will connect the dots and understand what we believe are the  pathways to undermine your identity, and by extension your agency.

There is an intentional assault on a way of comprehending life. The goal is to  destroy. This is done by trashing history and criminalising those who are the carriers of the defined disease - labelled “colonialism”.   The next step is to demoralise and suck people dry of hope creating visionless men and women. This  leads to a kind of death where,  in  the land of your birth, you have no “agency”  and the irony is not lost on us.  This is precisely the accusation levelled against “the colonial” who are the creators of the initial dispossession. The way of redress is what is being navigated right now. It is anything from retribution to restoration. But Gramsci, who we will introduce you to next time round,  does not allow restoration. It is good  you know why.

The Oliver Tambo vision of  South Africa is anathema to a new Nike-wearing marxist generation. They harbour a visceral intolerance, even hatred, for any  approach that leverages ALL our past, using ALL our social, technical, psychological  and spiritual complexities that comprise our  common heritage. This is their narrative: Mandela, Tambo and the 1994 leader cohort are deeply compromised.  They were bought out by colonial capitalists.


The activists  feed, even rely on, the  toxic bacteria of grinding poverty, injustice, resentment, entitlement, disappointment, covetousness and a generationally fuelled impatience with the pace of change.  Corruption doesn’t help either.

A sense of “denied justice” is a  powerful motivator that  legitimises anger. The target of this hatred are the perceived originators and now the current “owners” of this misery - the “colonials” - which is code for, in generic terms, the individualised world view asociated with northern hemisphere, western thinking and practice. Its embodiment just happens to reside in people with pale skins.

But in our first blog, as a scene set weʼll look at some key actors and their “virtue signalling” with comments. It is important to note and understand the branding. Nothing is insignificant. All actions are intentionally choreographed and grounded in deep ideological and psychological thinking.

Julius Malemaʼs “red beret” garb  looks to be borrowed from the failed Equadorian President,  Hugo Chavez. Chavez probably has minimal resonance here other than reducing his nation to squalor.  Fanon provides the intellectual component to the EFF uniform. The intention is really to offend - what can be more offensive to the more stoical mindset than watching the dignity of Parliament disregarded by worker clothing? The EFF are smart operators and superb virtue signallers. Their “parliamentary uniform” - the “Easyjet” orange jumpsuit is an effective visual hook, ideal for the TV camera. JuJu is a conditional democrat -  he lauds the Constitutional Court because it sides with him against President Zuma. This is further “virtue signalling” - at the SONA address as the Cheif Justice and his Bench parade in to Parliament the EFF cohort signal their respect with silence.   He is a consummate political operator where all influencing options are open. The end justifies the means.

Consider Mcebo Dlamini, the 32 year old Wits LLM student activist/apparent leader. He frequently sports the   PLO Arafat-famous, Keffiyeh Scarf at all major public events. This is intentional virtue signalling which,  interestingly, links him to the progressive student “rent a mob” currently rampaging the streets of major US cities protesting  Trump’s election.   Violence is always an option. The end justifies the means. The angry students he incites are really just useful potential cannon fodder - where the choreography requires   a few to go and collect a bullet at the hands of the police - and create an outpouring of national mayhem that will bring down Zuma’s government.

Chumani Maxwele, the UCT  management student who tipped excrement over UCTʼs Rhodes Statue is a colleague of Chumani. They drink the same koolaid.  The intention  is to offend colonialists by  attacking symbols of colonial aggression - burning paintings of Hall Founders at UCT, tipping excrement on Rhodes’ Statue and so on. The goal is to both enrage and demoralise. He succeeded in evoking the psychological response that Fanon urges. He is driven by racial hatred generated out of, and no more compelling than  the same psychological/spiritual swamp that drove PW Botha, HF Verwoerd, Eugene Terreblanche and their ilk - notwithstanding the irony. But, it feels as if , “progressives” and radicals are a humourless bunch.

That Maxwele inhabits the same behavioural excess as the “colonials”  is nevertheless good news. Evil, we suggest,  is not racial but universal, available, by choice, to all.   Because he is “on the right side of history” though, his racialism is acceptable or tolerated.



In our next blog we will introduce you to Gramsci and if there is space, Fanon (who got a passing mention this time round).


Simon Middleton

Partner at Noted Thinking